Case Information


CR09-25-4450 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Gabriel Isaac Carothers Defendant.

Case Number
CR09-25-4450

Court
Bonner County District Court

Judicial Officer
Jensen, Susie

File Date
11/10/2025

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Active - Pending

Party

State
State of Idaho

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Sherritt, Katie M.

Defendant
Carothers, Gabriel Isaac

DOB
XX/XX/1998

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Finney, Rex Adam Moyle

Retained

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney
Northam, Jay Edward

Retained

Attorney
State Public Defender-Bonner

Retained

Charge

Charges
Carothers, Gabriel Isaac
  DescriptionStatuteLevelDate
1Assault-Aggravated (With Deadly Weapon or Instrument)I18-905(a)Felony11/09/2025
2Driving Under the InfluenceI18-8004 {M}Misdemeanor11/09/2025
3Accident-Fail to Notify Upon Striking Fixtures on HighwayI49-1304Misdemeanor11/09/2025
4Accident-Fail to Give Immediate Notice of an AccidentI49-1305Misdemeanor11/09/2025

Bond Settings


Setting Date
11/10/2025
11/26/2025

Disposition Events

12/18/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Jensen, Susie

1
Assault-Aggravated (With Deadly Weapon or Instrument)
Not Guilty
2
Driving Under the Influence
Not Guilty
3
Accident-Fail to Notify Upon Striking Fixtures on Highway
Not Guilty
4
Accident-Fail to Give Immediate Notice of an Accident
Not Guilty

Events and Hearings


  • 11/10/2025 Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Original Type
    Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Hearing Time
    1:15 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Sherritt, Katie M.

    Defendant: Carothers, Gabriel I

  • 11/10/2025 New Case - Criminal

  • 11/10/2025 Criminal Complaint

  • 11/10/2025 Probable Cause Affidavit in Support of Arrest

    Comment
    and/or Refusal to Take Test

  • 11/10/2025 Probable Cause Order

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

  • 11/10/2025 Notification of Rights

    Comment
    Felony

  • 11/10/2025 Notification of Rights

    Comment
    Misdemeanor

  • 11/10/2025 Application for Attorney at Public Expense

  • 11/10/2025 Order Appointing State Public Defender

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

  • 11/10/2025 Conditions of Bail or Release

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

  • 11/10/2025 Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Preliminary Hearing 11/19/2025 @ 1:30PM

  • 11/10/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Comment
    Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

  • 11/10/2025 Jail Information Sheet

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

  • 11/10/2025 Affidavit in Support of Complaint or Warrant

    Comment
    Search Warrant

  • 11/10/2025 Search Warrant Issued

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Comment
    Search Warrant - Blood

  • 11/10/2025 Search Warrant Returned

  • 11/10/2025 Jail Information Sheet

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Comment
    AMENDED

  • 11/10/2025 Probable Cause Order

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Comment
    AMENDED

  • 11/10/2025 Notice to Defendant Regarding Release

    Judicial Officer
    Hagelberg, Luke

    Comment
    Released on Own Recognizance on Charges II, III, and IV Only

  • 11/12/2025 Conditions of Bail or Release

    Comment
    Signed by Defendant

  • 11/12/2025 Waiver of Extradition

  • 11/12/2025 Notice of Appearance

    Comment
    Request for Timely Preliminary Hearing & Motion for Bond Reduction - J Northam

  • 11/12/2025 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Defendant's

  • 11/13/2025 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Plaintiff's

  • 11/13/2025 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Plaintiff's

  • 11/13/2025 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    and Objections - Defendant's

  • 11/14/2025 Notice of Appearance

    Comment
    Request for Prelim Hearing, Request for Jury Trial, Motion to Suppress, and Request for Discovery - R. Finney

  • 11/14/2025 Notice of Substitution of Counsel

    Comment
    R. Finney for J. Northam

  • 11/17/2025 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Plaintiff's

  • 11/17/2025 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Plaintiff's

  • 11/19/2025 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    and Motion for Bond Reduction

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Sherritt, Katie M.

    Defendant: Carothers, Gabriel I

    Attorney of Record: Finney, Rex Adam Moyle

  • 11/19/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Comment
    Preliminary Hearing (Continued)

  • 11/19/2025 Jail Information Sheet

  • 11/19/2025 Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Preliminary Hearing (11/26/2025 @ 1:30 PM)

  • 11/26/2025 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    and Motion for Bond Reduction

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Sherritt, Katie M.

    Defendant: Carothers, Gabriel I

    Attorney of Record: Finney, Rex Adam Moyle

  • 11/26/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Comment
    Preliminary Hearing (Waived)

  • 11/26/2025 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Comment
    for Release on Own Recognizance with Conditions

  • 11/26/2025 Order Binding Defendant Over to District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Comment
    and Setting Arraignment (12/18/2025 @ 9:30 AM)

  • 11/26/2025 Preliminary Hearing Waived (Bound Over)

  • 11/26/2025 Jail Information Sheet

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

  • 11/26/2025 Notice to Defendant Regarding Release

    Judicial Officer
    Julian, Justin W.

    Comment
    Released on Own Recognizance

  • 12/01/2025 Felony Information Filed

  • 12/03/2025 Motion to Issue Warrant

    Comment
    for Failure to Comply with Conditions of Release

  • 12/03/2025 Motion to Withdraw

    Comment
    Warrant Request for Failure to Comply

  • 12/03/2025 Order on Motion

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    to Withdraw Warrant Request for Failure to Comply

  • 12/08/2025 Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Plaintiff's

  • 12/18/2025 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Hearing Time
    9:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    (No Rights Filed) Via Zoom

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Sherritt, Katie M.

    Defendant: Carothers, Gabriel Isaac

    Attorney of Record: Finney, Rex Adam Moyle

  • 12/18/2025 DC Arraignment: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    Phoebe Burns Less Than 100 Pages

  • 12/18/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    Arraignment - District Court

  • 12/18/2025 Appear & Plead Not Guilty

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

  • 12/18/2025 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    Pretrial Conference 3/16/2026 at 1:30 pm and Jury Trial 4/13/2026

  • 12/31/2025 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    2nd

  • 03/16/2026 Pre-trial Conference

    Original Type
    Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    (3 day Jury 4/13/2026) In Person

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Sherritt, Katie M.

    Defendant: Carothers, Gabriel Isaac

    Attorney of Record: Finney, Rex Adam Moyle

  • 03/16/2026 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    Phoebe Burns Less Than 100 Pages

  • 03/16/2026 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    Pre-trial Conference

  • 03/26/2026 Waiver of Speedy Trial

  • 03/26/2026 Stipulation to Continue

    Comment
    Jury Trial 04/13/2026 - 04/17/2026 9:00 AM

  • 03/26/2026 Agreement to Mediate

    Comment
    Stipulation

  • 03/27/2026 Order to Continue Trial Upon Stipulation or Motion

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Comment
    04/13/2026 - 04/17/2026 9:00 AM

  • 03/27/2026 Order for Mediation

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

  • 03/27/2026 Amended Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Pretrial Conference 8/3/2026 at 1:30 pm and Jury Trial 8/10/2026

  • 08/03/2026 Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Comment
    (3 day Jury 8/10/2026) In Person

  • 08/10/2026 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Jensen, Susie

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Comment
    (3 days)

Loading financial, please wait...