Case Information


CR03-23-06433 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Matthew B Karol Defendant.

Case Number
CR03-23-06433

Court
Bannock County District Court

Judicial Officer
Naftz, Robert C.

File Date
06/22/2023

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Closed

Party

State
State of Idaho

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

Defendant
Karol, Matthew B

DOB
XX/XX/1990

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Andrew, John Scott

Retained

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney
Martinez, David Robert

Retained

Attorney
Fry, Rilie Michael

Retained

Charge

Charges
Karol, Matthew B
  DescriptionStatuteLevelDate
1Battery-Aggravated (Cause Great Bodily Harm or Disability)I18-907(1)(a)Felony01/27/2023
2Rape-Resists but Resistance is Overcome by Force or ViolenceI18-6101(4)Felony01/27/2023

Bond Settings


Setting Date
9/7/2023
6/22/2023

Disposition Events

06/24/2024 Plea

Judicial Officer
Naftz, Robert C.

1
Battery-Aggravated (Cause Great Bodily Harm or Disability)
Guilty

11/13/2023 Plea

Judicial Officer
Naftz, Robert C.

1
Battery-Aggravated (Cause Great Bodily Harm or Disability)
Not Guilty
2
Rape-Resists but Resistance is Overcome by Force or Violence
None

06/24/2024 Disposition

Judicial Officer
Naftz, Robert C.

1
Battery-Aggravated (Cause Great Bodily Harm or Disability)
Guilty (Plea Agreement)

10/02/2023 Disposition

Judicial Officer
Thompson, Aaron N.

2
Rape-Resists but Resistance is Overcome by Force or Violence
Dismissed by Court

08/01/2024 Felony Sentence

1
Battery-Aggravated (Cause Great Bodily Harm or Disability)
Felony Sentence

Fee Totals


$245.50

$500.00


Fee Totals

$745.50

Confinement

Type: State Prison

Facility: Idaho Department of Correction

Effective Date: 08/01/2024

Determinate: 3 Years

Indeterminate: 7 Years

Pre-Sentence Credit for Time Served

Credit Term: 407 Days


Fee Totals


$100.00

$500.00

$2,000.00


Fee Totals

$2,600.00

Events and Hearings


  • 06/22/2023 New Case - Criminal

  • 06/22/2023 Criminal Complaint

  • 06/22/2023 Affidavit of Probable Cause

    Comment
    Redacted

  • 06/22/2023 Affidavit of Probable Cause

    Comment
    Unredacted

  • 06/22/2023 Request

    Comment
    for Bond in the Amount of $75,000.00

  • 06/22/2023 Probable Cause Order

    Comment
    Minute Entry

  • 06/22/2023 Warrant/Det Order Issued - Arrest

  • 08/31/2023 Notification of Rights

  • 08/31/2023 Application for Public Defender

  • 09/07/2023 Video Arraignment

    Original Type
    Video Arraignment

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

  • 09/07/2023 Arraignment

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Notification of Rights

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Application for Public Defender

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Order Appointing Public Defender

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Bond Set

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

    Comment
    $75,000.00 and NCO

  • 09/07/2023 Custody Order of Sheriff

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Murray, Bryan K.

  • 09/07/2023 Order Quashing and Recalling Warrant

    Comment
    Email Bannock County Dispatch

  • 09/07/2023 Warrant Quashed or Recalled

  • 09/07/2023 No Contact Order

  • 09/08/2023 Warrant Returned - No Service

  • 09/13/2023 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Defendant's

  • 09/18/2023 Response to Request for Discovery

  • 09/18/2023 Motion to Transport

  • 09/19/2023 Order to Transport

    Comment
    Bannock County Sheriff - Ada County Jail to Bannock County Jail

  • 09/20/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Thompson, Aaron N.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    In Ada County Jail

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

  • 09/20/2023 Court Minutes

  • 09/27/2023 Brief Filed

    Comment
    on Bind Over Issue Presented at Preliminary Hearing

  • 10/02/2023 Order Binding Defendant Over to District Court

    Comment
    Count 1 - Bind Over; Count 2 - Dismissed

  • 10/02/2023 Felony Information Filed

  • 10/02/2023 Bound Over (after Prelim)

  • 10/03/2023 Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 10/06/2023 Notice of Hearing

  • 10/30/2023 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Reset

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

  • 10/31/2023 Court Minutes

  • 10/31/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 11/13/2023 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

  • 11/13/2023 Appear & Plead Not Guilty

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

  • 11/13/2023 Order for Preliminary Hearing Transcript

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

  • 11/13/2023 Custody Order of Sheriff

    Comment
    $75,000

  • 11/14/2023 Court Minutes

  • 11/14/2023 Notice of Jury Trial Setting, Pretrial Conference and Order

  • 11/14/2023 Request for Discovery

  • 11/30/2023 Motion for Bond Reduction

  • 11/30/2023 Proposed Order Denied

    Comment
    To Reduce Bond

  • 11/30/2023 Objection

    Comment
    To Defendant's Motion for Bond Reduction

  • 02/01/2024 Transcript Filed with the Trial Court

    Comment
    Preliminary Hearing 9-20-23

  • 02/26/2024 Pre-trial Conference

    Original Type
    Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    4:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

  • 02/29/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/12/2024 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 03/13/2024 Plea Agreement

  • 03/13/2024 Guilty Plea Advisory

  • 03/13/2024 IDOC Agreement of Supervision

  • 03/13/2024 PSI Face Sheet

  • 03/14/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/14/2024 Motion for Bond Reduction

    Comment
    or OR Release

  • 03/15/2024 Objection

    Comment
    to Defendant's Motion for Bond Reduction

  • 03/18/2024 Proposed Order Denied

    Comment
    Bond Reduction

  • 04/01/2024 Motion to Amend

  • 04/01/2024 Response

    Comment
    to Motion to Amend Prosecuting Attorney's

  • 04/02/2024 Order

    Comment
    to Amend Information

  • 04/02/2024 Amended Information

  • 04/08/2024 Change of Plea

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 04/08/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 04/29/2024 Change of Plea

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 04/29/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 05/13/2024 Change of Plea

    Original Type
    Change of Plea

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

    Public Defender: Andrew, John Scott

  • 05/13/2024 Custody Order of Sheriff

    Comment
    $75,000

  • 05/13/2024 Court Minutes

  • 05/13/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 06/03/2024 Change of Plea

    Original Type
    Change of Plea

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant

    Public Defender: Andrew, John Scott

  • 06/04/2024 Court Minutes

  • 06/04/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 06/24/2024 Change of Plea

    Original Type
    Change of Plea

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

    Public Defender: Andrew, John Scott

  • 06/24/2024 Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    4:00 PM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 06/24/2024 Custody Order of Sheriff

    Comment
    $75,000

  • 06/25/2024 Court Minutes

    Comment
    and Order

  • 06/25/2024 Pre-Sentence Investigation Evaluation Ordered

  • 06/25/2024 Letter

    Comment
    Requesting Psychosexual from Another Judge

  • 07/09/2024 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 07/16/2024 Motion

    Comment
    For Release on Own Recognizance

  • 07/17/2024 Proposed Order Denied

    Comment
    Releasing Defendant on Own Recognizance

  • 07/17/2024 Notice

    Comment
    of Eligibility for Treatment Court - ineligible

  • 07/17/2024 Order Releasing Presentence Investigation Report - 3rd Party

  • 07/17/2024 Pre-Sentence Report

    Comment
    CR01-23-2018

  • 07/17/2024 Evaluation/Assessment Filed

    Comment
    Psychosexual Evaluation CR01-23-2018

  • 07/25/2024 Pre-Sentence Report

  • 07/26/2024 Court Minutes

    Comment
    and Order Amended

  • 07/31/2024 Materials in Support

    Comment
    Defendant's Sentencing Submissions - Letters of Support

  • 08/01/2024 Sentencing

    Original Type
    Sentencing

    Judicial Officer
    Naftz, Robert C.

    Hearing Time
    2:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Tognetti, Erin Jennifer

    Defendant: Karol, Matthew B

    Public Defender: Andrew, John Scott

  • 08/01/2024 Custody Order of Sheriff

    Comment
    Prison

  • 08/01/2024 No Contact Order

    Comment
    Amended

  • 08/01/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Comment
    Stephanie Davis

  • 08/01/2024 Sealed Order Correcting Information in Presentence Report

  • 08/01/2024 Case Closed

  • 08/02/2024 Court Minutes

  • 08/02/2024 Judgment of Conviction

Loading financial, please wait...