Case Information


CR12-25-0322 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Gary Joel Sullivan Defendant.

Case Number
CR12-25-0322

Court
Butte County District Court

Judicial Officer
Simpson, Darren B.

File Date
07/14/2025

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Closed

Party

State
State of Idaho

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Stephens, Steve L.

Defendant
Sullivan, Gary Joel

DOB
XX/XX/1986

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Pendlebury, James Andrew

Retained

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney
Pendlebury, James Andrew

Retained

Attorney
Dummar, Dan Cid

Retained

Attorney
State Public Defender-Butte

Retained

Charge

Charges
Sullivan, Gary Joel
  DescriptionCitationStatuteLevelDate
1Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)ISP4456000729I18-8006Felony07/12/2025
2Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)ISP4456000729I18-8006Felony07/12/2025
3Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)ISP4456000729I18-8006Felony07/12/2025
4Driving Under the Influence-(Third or Subsequent Offense) I18-8004 {F}Felony07/12/2025
5Controlled Substance-Possession of I37-2732(c)(3)_MMisdemeanor07/12/2025
6Alcoholic Beverage-Consume or Possess Open Container by Driver I23-505(2)_MMisdemeanor07/12/2025
7Drug Paraphernalia-Use or Possess With Intent to Use I37-2734A(1)Misdemeanor07/12/2025

Bond Settings


Setting Date
7/14/2025

Bond


Bond TypeBond NumberBond AmountCurrent Bond Status
Surety Bond050-8806045440000.00Exonerated

Disposition Events

01/13/2026 Plea

Judicial Officer
Simpson, Darren B.

1
Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)
Guilty

09/16/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Simpson, Darren B.

2
Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)
Not Guilty
3
Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)
Not Guilty
4
Driving Under the Influence-(Third or Subsequent Offense)
Not Guilty

07/22/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Randall, Neal S

5
Controlled Substance-Possession of
Not Guilty
6
Alcoholic Beverage-Consume or Possess Open Container by Driver
Not Guilty
7
Drug Paraphernalia-Use or Possess With Intent to Use
Not Guilty

03/10/2026 Disposition

Judicial Officer
Simpson, Darren B.

1
Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)
Guilty (Plea Agreement)

03/10/2026 Felony Sentence

1
Driving-Under the Influence (Aggravated)
Felony Sentence

Fee Totals


$290.50

$2,000.00

$500.00


Fee Totals

$2,790.50

Confinement

Type: State Prison

Facility: Idaho Department of Correction

Effective Date: 03/10/2026

Determinate: 2 Years

Indeterminate: 8 Years

Pre-Sentence Credit for Time Served

Credit Term: 3 Days


Events and Hearings


  • 07/14/2025 Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Original Type
    Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Judicial Officer
    Savage, Ralph L.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Stephens, Steve L.

    Defendant: Sullivan, Gary Joel

  • 07/14/2025 New Case - Criminal

  • 07/14/2025 Citation Filed

  • 07/14/2025 Criminal Complaint

  • 07/14/2025 Affidavit of Probable Cause

  • 07/14/2025 Notification of Rights

  • 07/14/2025 Bond Posted - Surety

  • 07/15/2025 Court Minutes

  • 07/16/2025 Notice of Assignment (PD)

  • 07/21/2025 Notice of Appearance

  • 07/21/2025 Plea of Not Guilty

  • 07/21/2025 Demand for Jury Trial

  • 07/21/2025 Request for Discovery

  • 07/21/2025 Letter

    Comment
    From Attorney Requesting an ALS Hearing

  • 07/21/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Robert Tollman

  • 07/21/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Elizabeth Tollman

  • 07/21/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    ISP Officer Dakota Wilson

  • 07/21/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    ISP Officer Johnathan Funderburk

  • 07/21/2025 Motion for Zoom Hearing

    Comment
    Witnesses

  • 07/22/2025 Order

    Comment
    Allowing State's Witness to Appear Via Zoom

  • 07/22/2025 Notice of Appearance

  • 07/22/2025 Request for Discovery

  • 07/22/2025 Motion to Continue

  • 07/22/2025 Stipulation to Continue

  • 07/22/2025 Waiver of Time for Preliminary Hearing

  • 07/23/2025 Order to Continue

  • 07/23/2025 Substitution of Counsel

  • 08/06/2025 Motion

  • 08/06/2025 Subpoena Issued

  • 08/06/2025 Subpoena Issued

  • 08/06/2025 Subpoena Issued

  • 08/06/2025 Subpoena Issued

  • 08/07/2025 Motion to Withdraw

  • 08/07/2025 Motion to Shorten Time

  • 08/07/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 08/08/2025 Stipulation

  • 08/08/2025 Motion for Zoom Hearing

  • 08/11/2025 Order

    Comment
    Allowing the State's Witness to Appear via Zoom

  • 08/11/2025 Order to Shorten Time

  • 08/12/2025 Order

    Comment
    Granting Motion to Appear via Zoom

  • 08/14/2025 Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Randall, Neal S

    Hearing Time
    02:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Stephens, Steve L.

    Defendant: Sullivan, Gary Joel

  • 08/14/2025 Affidavit Verifying Income

  • 08/18/2025 Order Appointing State Public Defender

  • 08/19/2025 Order Granting Leave to Withdraw as Atty of Record

  • 08/19/2025 Notice of Assignment (PD)

  • 08/20/2025 Notice of Appearance

  • 08/20/2025 Request for Discovery and Inspection

  • 08/25/2025 Court Minutes

  • 08/25/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 08/26/2025 Waiver of Preliminary Hearing

  • 08/26/2025 Order Waiving Preliminary Hearing (Written Waiver)

    Judicial Officer
    Randall, Neal S

  • 08/26/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 08/28/2025 Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Randall, Neal S

    Hearing Time
    02:00 PM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 09/10/2025 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 09/15/2025 Felony Information Filed

  • 09/16/2025 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Simpson, Darren B.

    Hearing Time
    10:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Stephens, Steve L.

    Defendant: Sullivan, Gary Joel

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

  • 09/22/2025 Court Minutes

  • 09/22/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 01/07/2026 Plea Agreement

  • 01/13/2026 Change of Plea

    Original Type
    Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Simpson, Darren B.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Stephens, Steve L.

    Defendant: Sullivan, Gary Joel

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

  • 01/13/2026 Notice of Hearing

  • 01/14/2026 Order for Pre-Sentence Report (PSI)

  • 01/22/2026 Court Minutes

  • 02/18/2026 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Simpson, Darren B.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 03/03/2026 Pre-Sentence Report

  • 03/04/2026 Notice of Filing

    Comment
    of Character Reference Letters

  • 03/04/2026 Notice of Eligibility for Treatment Court

  • 03/04/2026 Treatment Court Tracking Log

    Comment
    Accepted into Bonneville County Felony Treatment Court

  • 03/10/2026 Sentencing

    Original Type
    Sentencing

    Judicial Officer
    Simpson, Darren B.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Stephens, Steve L.

    Defendant: Sullivan, Gary Joel

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

    Public Defender: Pendlebury, James Andrew

  • 03/12/2026 Court Minutes

  • 03/12/2026 Judgment of Conviction

  • 03/12/2026 Bond Exonerated

Loading financial, please wait...