Case Information


CR42-23-1772 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Louis H Dorfman Defendant.

Case Number
CR42-23-1772

Court
Twin Falls County District Court

Judicial Officer
Cluff, Benjamin J.

File Date
02/27/2023

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Active - Pending

Party

State
State of Idaho

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Seamons, Justin Royce
Attorney
Loebs, Grant P.
Attorney
Twiggs, Jacob Dance
Attorney
Willmore, Kiel Rigby

Defendant
Dorfman, Louis H

DOB
XX/XX/1992

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
McRae, Steven Rey

Public Defender

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney
Zollinger, Clayne S., Jr

Retained

Attorney
Zollinger, Clayne S., Jr

Retained

Attorney
Hurley, Joseph Francis

Retained

Attorney
Henry, Richard Kevin

Retained

Attorney
Cannon, Craig Michael

Retained

Attorney
O'Brien, Lisa M.

Retained

Attorney
Office of the Public Defender-Twin Falls

Public Defender

Attorney
Office of the Public Defender-Twin Falls

Public Defender

Charge

Charges
Dorfman, Louis H
  DescriptionStatuteLevelDate
1Property-Malicious Injury to PropertyI18-7001(2)Felony02/25/2023
2Unlawful EntryI18-7034(1)MMisdemeanor02/25/2023
3Property-Malicious Injury to PropertyI18-7001(2)Felony02/25/2023

Bond Settings


Setting Date
3/19/2024

Disposition Events

04/15/2024 Plea

Judicial Officer
Cluff, Benjamin J.

1
Property-Malicious Injury to Property
Not Guilty
2
Unlawful Entry
Not Guilty
3
Property-Malicious Injury to Property
Not Guilty

Events and Hearings


  • 02/27/2023 Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Original Type
    Initial Appearance - Felony Magistrate Court

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Hearing Time
    1:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

  • 02/27/2023 New Case - Criminal

  • 02/27/2023 Criminal Complaint

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

  • 02/27/2023 Affidavit in Support of Complaint or Warrant

  • 02/27/2023 Sheriff's Inmate Screening Report

  • 02/27/2023 Vertical Judge Selected

    Comment
    Cluff

  • 02/27/2023 County Jail Packet

  • 02/27/2023 Notification of Rights

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

  • 02/27/2023 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Comment
    waived counsel

  • 02/27/2023 Bond Set

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Comment
    $100,000

  • 02/27/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

  • 03/02/2023 Affidavit in Support of Complaint or Warrant

  • 03/10/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Comment
    Cluff

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 03/10/2023 Court Minutes

  • 03/10/2023 Continued

  • 03/10/2023 Order Appointing Public Defender

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Comment
    for limited purposes

  • 03/10/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 03/10/2023 Response to Request for Discovery

  • 03/10/2023 Request for Discovery

  • 03/10/2023 Motion

    Comment
    for Competency Examination

  • 03/10/2023 Notice

    Comment
    to Withdraw the Request for Discovery

  • 03/10/2023 Notice

    Comment
    to Withdraw the Response to Request for Discovery

  • 03/13/2023 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Campbell, Calvin H.

    Comment
    for Competency Examination

  • 03/31/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Comment
    Cluff

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

  • 03/31/2023 Court Minutes

  • 03/31/2023 Continued

  • 03/31/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 04/07/2023 18-211 Competency Evaluation Report

    Comment
    Idaho Code 18-211

  • 04/19/2023 Order

    Comment
    Of Commitment and Order to Transport

  • 04/19/2023 Disposition for Behavioral Health Facility

    Comment
    Disposition

  • 05/05/2023 Letter

    Comment
    Override Letter to Court

  • 05/11/2023 Notice

    Comment
    of Conflict

  • 05/12/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Comment
    Cluff

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

  • 05/12/2023 Court Minutes

  • 05/12/2023 Continued

  • 05/12/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 05/24/2023 Notice of Substitution of Counsel

    Comment
    as Conflict Attorney

  • 05/24/2023 Request for Discovery and Inspection

  • 06/05/2023 Request for Discovery

  • 06/05/2023 Response to Request for Discovery

  • 06/05/2023 Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 06/05/2023 Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 06/08/2023 Letter

    Comment
    Medical Record

  • 06/09/2023 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Comment
    terminating commitment pursuant to Idaho Code 18-212

  • 06/09/2023 Order to Transport

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

  • 06/23/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Comment
    Cluff

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

  • 06/23/2023 Court Minutes

  • 06/23/2023 Continued

  • 06/23/2023 Notice of Remote Hearing

  • 07/21/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Harmer, Benjamin D.

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

  • 07/21/2023 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Bollar, Rick L.

  • 07/21/2023 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Bollar, Rick L.

  • 08/01/2023 Waiver of Preliminary Hearing

    Comment
    Waiver of Preliminary Hearing

  • 08/01/2023 Guilty Plea Advisory

  • 08/01/2023 PSI Face Sheet

  • 08/01/2023 IDOC Agreement of Supervision

  • 08/03/2023 Order Waiving Preliminary Hearing (Written Waiver)

    Judicial Officer
    Kershaw, Thomas D., Jr

  • 08/03/2023 Preliminary Hearing Waived (Bound Over)

  • 08/11/2023 Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Harmer, Benjamin D.

    Hearing Time
    8:15 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 08/22/2023 Felony Information Filed

  • 08/24/2023 Notice of Hearing

  • 08/24/2023 Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 09/11/2023 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Willmore, Kiel Rigby

  • 09/11/2023 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Amy Fleming

  • 09/11/2023 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 09/20/2023 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 11/13/2023 Proposed Order Denied

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Order for Competnecy Examination

  • 11/20/2023 Order of Commitment

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    and Order to Transport

  • 01/18/2024 18-211 Competency Evaluation Report

    Comment
    Idaho Code 18-211

  • 01/29/2024 Notice of Substitution of Counsel

    Comment
    Notice of Substitution of Counsel

  • 01/29/2024 Notice of Service of Discovery Requests

    Comment
    Notice of Service of Defendant's Requests for Discovery

  • 01/29/2024 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Defendant's Request for Discovery

  • 02/09/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Response to Request for Discovery

  • 03/06/2024 Motion for Bond Reduction

  • 03/06/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/06/2024 Motion

    Comment
    for Termination of 18-212 Commitment Order

  • 03/07/2024 Order Terminating Commitment, Status Hearing & Transport

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 03/13/2024 Victim's Rights Notification Form

  • 03/19/2024 Motion for Bond Reduction

    Original Type
    Motion for Bond Reduction

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Twiggs, Jacob Dance

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 03/19/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Butler, John K.

    Comment
    Debbie Wilks

  • 03/19/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Butler, John K.

  • 03/22/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/28/2024 Motion to Continue

  • 03/29/2024 Order to Continue

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 03/29/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/29/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 04/15/2024 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Willmore, Kiel Rigby

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 04/15/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Helen Miller

  • 04/15/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/15/2024 Not Guilty Plea & Request for Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/15/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/16/2024 Scheduling Order

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Criminal Case Scheduling Order

  • 05/29/2024 Motion to Withdraw

    Comment
    Motion to Withdraw as Attorney of Record

  • 05/30/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Notice of Hearing

  • 06/13/2024 Notice of Substitution of Counsel

  • 06/13/2024 Request for Discovery

  • 06/14/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

  • 06/17/2024 Motion to Withdraw as Attorney

    Original Type
    Motion to Withdraw as Attorney

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 06/17/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 06/17/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Denise Warren

  • 06/18/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 06/20/2024 Motion for Zoom Hearing

    Comment
    Motion to Allow Attorney for the Defendant and Defendant to Appear via Zoom

  • 06/21/2024 Proposed Order Denied

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Order to Allow Attorney for the Defendant and Defendant to Appear via Zoom

  • 06/24/2024 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    10:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 06/24/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Debbie WilksN

  • 06/24/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 06/24/2024 Waiver of Speedy Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    on the Record

  • 06/25/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 07/19/2024 Order to Transport

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 07/22/2024 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    11:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 07/22/2024 Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    4:00 PM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 07/22/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Debbie Wilks

  • 07/22/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 07/23/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 07/30/2024 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 08/19/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 08/19/2024 Notice

    Comment
    Notice of Intent to Offer Evidence of Prior Felony Conviction Pursuant to I.R.E. 609

  • 08/19/2024 Notice

    Comment
    Notice of Compliance

  • 08/19/2024 Proposed Jury Instructions

    Comment
    Proposed Jury Instructions and Verdict Form

  • 08/20/2024 Witness List

  • 08/20/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 08/30/2024 Motion to Continue

  • 08/30/2024 Motion for Appointment of Public Defender

    Comment
    Motion to Appoint Conflict Public Defender

  • 09/03/2024 Pre-trial Conference

    Original Type
    Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    4:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 09/03/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Carol Greco

  • 09/03/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 09/04/2024 Order to Continue

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 09/04/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 09/10/2024 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 09/10/2024 Order of Appointment of Conflict Public Defender

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 09/30/2024 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    10:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 09/30/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Mary Barrows

  • 09/30/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 10/07/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 10/15/2024 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    10:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

  • 10/15/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Helen Miller

  • 10/15/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 10/16/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 10/17/2024 Order Appointing State Public Defender

  • 10/22/2024 Notice of Assignment (PD)

    Comment
    Notice of Assignment of Counsel

  • 10/22/2024 Request for Discovery

  • 10/31/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

  • 10/31/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery

  • 12/18/2024 Motion

    Comment
    for Competency Evaluation Pursuant to Idaho Code 18-211

  • 12/18/2024 Affidavit

    Comment
    of Steven R. McRae

  • 12/18/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Re: Motion to Suppress

  • 12/18/2024 Notice of Hearing

    Comment
    Amended Notice of Hearing Re: Motion for Competency Evaluation Pursuant to Idaho Code 18-211

  • 12/23/2024 Pre-trial Conference

    Original Type
    Pre-trial Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    4:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    Also motion for additional competency eval

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant: Dorfman, Louis H

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: McRae, Steven Rey

  • 12/23/2024 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Sharon Lange

  • 12/23/2024 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 12/31/2024 Order for Competency Evaluation and Order Allowing Access

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Idaho Code 18-211 or 18-212

  • 01/02/2025 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 01/13/2025 Letter

  • 01/16/2025 Order for Competency Evaluation and Order Allowing Access

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Idaho Code 18-211 or 18-212

  • 01/27/2025 18-211 Competency Evaluation Report

    Comment
    Confidential Forensic/Psychological Evaluation

  • 01/28/2025 Order for Commitment, Lacks Fitness to Proceed

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 01/29/2025 Disposition for Behavioral Health Facility

    Comment
    Disposition

  • 04/04/2025 Health & Welfare Report to The Court

    Comment
    Report to the court

  • 04/04/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 04/09/2025 Motion for Zoom Hearing

    Comment
    Motion to Appear via Zoom

  • 04/10/2025 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    on Motion to Appear via ZOOM

  • 04/11/2025 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    ZOOM

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: McRae, Steven Rey

  • 04/11/2025 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Sondra Black

  • 04/11/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/14/2025 Order Terminating Commitment, Status Hearing & Transport

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Order Terminating Commitment Pursuant to Idaho Code 18-212

  • 04/14/2025 Order to Transport

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/14/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 04/21/2025 Status Conference

    Original Type
    Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    10:15 AM

    Result
    Hearing Continued

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Seamons, Justin Royce

    Defendant

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: McRae, Steven Rey

  • 04/21/2025 DC Hearing Held: Court Reporter: # of Pages:

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Comment
    Deirdre Weyer

  • 04/21/2025 Court Minutes

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/21/2025 Continued

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 04/21/2025 Notice of Hearing

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

  • 05/16/2025 Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Cluff, Benjamin J.

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

Loading financial, please wait...