Case Information


CR40-24-0101 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Justin Gerald Karl Defendant.

Case Number
CR40-24-0101

Court
Shoshone County District Court

Judicial Officer
Duggan (District), Barbara

File Date
01/24/2024

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Closed

Party

State
State of Idaho

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

Defendant
Karl, Justin Gerald

DOB
XX/XX/1981

 

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney
Sergeant, Carl Scott, Jr

Retained

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney
Schwartz, Christopher David

Retained

Charge

Charges
Karl, Justin Gerald
  DescriptionCitationStatuteLevelDate
1Controlled Substance-Possession of I37-2732(c)(1) {F}Felony01/23/2024
2CHILDREN-INJURY TO CHILD-ADULT TRANSPORTS MINOR IN VEHICLE WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCEISP4352000338I18-1501(3) {M}Misdemeanor01/23/2024
3DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCEISP4352000338I18-8004(1)(a) {M}Misdemeanor01/23/2024
4CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE-POSSESSION OF MARIJUANAISP4352000338I37-2732(c)(3) {M}{MARIJUANA}Misdemeanor01/23/2024
5DRUG PARAPHERNALIA-USE OR POSSESS WITH INTENT TO USEISP4352000338I37-2734A(1)Misdemeanor01/23/2024
6ARRESTS & SEIZURES-RESISTING OR OBSTRUCTING OFFICERSISP4352000338I18-705Misdemeanor01/23/2024

Bond Settings


Setting Date
2/20/2024
6/10/2024

Bond


Bond TypeBond NumberBond AmountCurrent Bond Status
Cash Bond 20000.00Forfeited

Disposition Events

03/11/2024 Plea

Judicial Officer
Duggan (District), Barbara

2
CHILDREN-INJURY TO CHILD-ADULT TRANSPORTS MINOR IN VEHICLE WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE
Not Guilty
3
DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE
Not Guilty
4
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE-POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA
Not Guilty
5
DRUG PARAPHERNALIA-USE OR POSSESS WITH INTENT TO USE
Not Guilty
6
ARRESTS & SEIZURES-RESISTING OR OBSTRUCTING OFFICERS
Not Guilty
1
Controlled Substance-Possession of
Not Guilty

09/24/2025 Disposition

Judicial Officer
Duggan (District), Barbara

2
CHILDREN-INJURY TO CHILD-ADULT TRANSPORTS MINOR IN VEHICLE WHILE UNDER THE INFLUENCE
Acquittal
3
DRIVING UNDER THE INFLUENCE
Acquittal
4
CONTROLLED SUBSTANCE-POSSESSION OF MARIJUANA
Dismissed by Court
5
DRUG PARAPHERNALIA-USE OR POSSESS WITH INTENT TO USE
Guilty (After Trial)
6
ARRESTS & SEIZURES-RESISTING OR OBSTRUCTING OFFICERS
Guilty (After Trial)
1
Controlled Substance-Possession of
Guilty (After Trial)

09/24/2025 Felony Sentence

1
Controlled Substance-Possession of
Felony Sentence

Fee Totals


$285.50

$500.00

$132.00


Fee Totals

$917.50

Condition - Adult

1. Other Condition, dna & fingerprint thru RDU, 09/24/2025, Active 09/24/2025


Confinement

Type: State Prison

Facility: Idaho Department of Correction

Effective Date: 09/24/2025

Determinate: 2 Years

Indeterminate: 2 Years

Retained Jurisdiction

Retained Jurisdiction: 365 Days

Pre-Sentence Credit for Time Served

Credit Term: 129 Days


09/24/2025 Misdemeanor Sentence

5
DRUG PARAPHERNALIA-USE OR POSSESS WITH INTENT TO USE
Misdemeanor Sentence

Confinement

Type: County Jail

Facility: Shoshone County Public Safety Facility

Term: 129 Days

Effective Date: 09/24/2025

Pre-Sentence Credit for Time Served

Credit Term: 129 Days


09/24/2025 Misdemeanor Sentence

6
ARRESTS & SEIZURES-RESISTING OR OBSTRUCTING OFFICERS
Misdemeanor Sentence

Confinement

Type: County Jail

Facility: Shoshone County Public Safety Facility

Term: 129 Days

Effective Date: 09/24/2025

Pre-Sentence Credit for Time Served

Credit Term: 129 Days


Events and Hearings


  • 01/24/2024 Arraignment

    Original Type
    Arraignment

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Hearing Time
    1:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

  • 01/24/2024 New Case - Criminal

  • 01/24/2024 Citation Filed

  • 01/24/2024 Amended Complaint Filed

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Comment
    Citation ISP4352000338

  • 01/24/2024 Affidavit of Probable Cause

  • 01/24/2024 Notification of Rights

    Comment
    All Refused and Blank

  • 01/24/2024 Application for Public Defender

    Comment
    Blank

  • 01/24/2024 Probable Cause Order

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

  • 01/24/2024 Court Minutes

  • 01/24/2024 Order for Competency Evaluation and Order to Stay Proceeding

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Comment
    Idaho Code 20-519A

  • 01/24/2024 Temporary Order Entered

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Comment
    PD Appointment

  • 02/01/2024 Notice of Appearance

    Comment
    NOA, Request For Timely Preliminary Hearing, Motion for Bond Reduction and Notice of Hearing

  • 02/01/2024 Demand for Jury Trial

    Comment
    Defendant's Plea of Not Guilty and Demand for Jury Trial

  • 02/01/2024 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Defendant's

  • 02/17/2024 18-211 Competency Evaluation Report

    Comment
    Mental Health Evaluation

  • 02/20/2024 Arraignment

    Original Type
    Arraignment

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Hearing Time
    1:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

  • 02/20/2024 Court Minutes

  • 02/20/2024 Notice of Remote Hearing

    Comment
    PRELIM

  • 02/20/2024 Conditions of Bail or Release

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Comment
    $20,000

  • 02/20/2024 Findings of Competency I.C. 18-211, 18-212

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

  • 02/21/2024 Application for Public Defender

  • 02/21/2024 Notification of Rights

    Comment
    felony

  • 02/21/2024 Notification of Rights

    Comment
    misdemeanor

  • 02/21/2024 Notification of Subsequent/Enhanced Penalties

  • 02/22/2024 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Myers, T

  • 02/22/2024 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Adams, W

  • 02/28/2024 Notice of Intent to Present 404b Evidence At Trial

  • 02/28/2024 Request for Discovery

    Comment
    State's

  • 02/28/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    State's Response and Notice of Compliance

  • 02/29/2024 Preliminary Hearing

    Original Type
    Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer(s)
    McGee, Daniel J., Oxendine, Keisha

    Hearing Time
    8:30 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

  • 02/29/2024 Preliminary Hearing

    Judicial Officer(s)
    McGee, Daniel J., Oxendine, Keisha

    Hearing Time
    1:30 PM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 02/29/2024 Court Minutes

  • 03/01/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    Defendants

  • 03/01/2024 Order Waiving Preliminary Hearing (On the Record)

    Judicial Officer
    McGee, Daniel J.

  • 03/01/2024 Preliminary Hearing Waived (Bound Over)

  • 03/01/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/06/2024 Felony Information Filed

  • 03/08/2024 Motion for Bond Reduction

    Comment
    Motion for Recognizance Release or Reduction of Bond

  • 03/08/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/08/2024 Motion to Shorten Time

  • 03/08/2024 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Comment
    to Shorten Time

  • 03/11/2024 Arraignment - District Court

    Original Type
    Arraignment - District Court

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

  • 03/11/2024 Motion for Bond Reduction

    Original Type
    Motion for Bond Reduction

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Comment
    RELEASE

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

  • 03/11/2024 Court Minutes

  • 03/13/2024 Notice of Hearing

  • 03/14/2024 Substitution of Counsel

  • 04/02/2024 Motion to Suppress

  • 04/23/2024 Notice to Defendant Regarding Release

  • 04/29/2024 Response to Request for Discovery

    Comment
    State's Response and Notice of Compliance With Defendant's Request for Discovery

  • 06/10/2024 Pre Trial

    Original Type
    Pre Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    2:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: Sergeant, Carl Scott, Jr

  • 06/10/2024 Court Minutes

  • 06/10/2024 Notice of Forfeiture of Cash Bail

  • 06/11/2024 Warrant Issued - Bench

  • 06/11/2024 Failure to Appear, Order of Forfeiture and for Bench Warrant

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 07/22/2024 Status Conference

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    2:00 PM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 08/14/2024 Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Cancel Reason
    Vacated

  • 12/12/2024 Order Releasing Cash Bail

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 12/12/2024 Bond Forfeited

  • 07/07/2025 Warrant Returned - Served

  • 07/08/2025 Arraignment

    Original Type
    Arraignment

    Judicial Officer
    Oxendine, Keisha

    Hearing Time
    1:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: Sergeant, Carl Scott, Jr

  • 07/08/2025 Court Minutes

  • 07/08/2025 Notice of Hearing

  • 07/14/2025 Summary of Expected Expert Testimony

    Comment
    Expert Witness Disclosure - Daisy Ricker

  • 07/14/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Subpoena - Daisy Ricker

  • 08/07/2025 Motion for Bond Reduction

  • 08/07/2025 Letter

  • 08/29/2025 Motion

    Comment
    Withdrawal of MTS

  • 09/02/2025 Motion

    Comment
    for Appropriate Clothing

  • 09/02/2025 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Comment
    Granting Motion for Clothing

  • 09/03/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Subpoena - Tim Myers

  • 09/03/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Subpoena - Will Adams

  • 09/03/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Subpoena - Sam Rodier

  • 09/10/2025 Witness List

    Comment
    Defendant's Witness List

  • 09/10/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    D.Ricker

  • 09/10/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    S.Rodier

  • 09/10/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    T.Meyers

  • 09/10/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    W.Adams

  • 09/15/2025 Pre Trial

    Original Type
    Pre Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    2:00 PM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: Sergeant, Carl Scott, Jr

  • 09/15/2025 Order

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Comment
    setting trial priority

  • 09/15/2025 Court Minutes

  • 09/16/2025 Witness List

    Comment
    State's Witness List

  • 09/16/2025 Exhibit List/Log

    Comment
    State's Exhibit List

  • 09/16/2025 Proposed Jury Instructions

    Comment
    State's Requested Jury Instructions

  • 09/17/2025 Proposed Jury Instructions

    Comment
    Defense's Proposed Jury Instructions

  • 09/17/2025 Witness List

  • 09/17/2025 Exhibit List/Log

  • 09/17/2025 Subpoena Issued

    Comment
    Subpoena-H.Manis

  • 09/22/2025 Exhibit List/Log

    Comment
    Defendant's Amended Exhibit List

  • 09/23/2025 Jury Trial

    Original Type
    Jury Trial

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

    Hearing Time
    9:00 AM

    Result
    Hearing Held

    Parties Present

    State: State of Idaho

    Prosecuting Attorney: Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney

    Defendant: Karl, Justin Gerald

    Public Defender - Conflict Counsel: Sergeant, Carl Scott, Jr

  • 09/23/2025 Jury Trial Started

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/23/2025 Jury Peremptory Challenge Work Sheet

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/23/2025 Court Minutes

    Comment
    250 pages-court reporter

  • 09/24/2025 Jury Seating Chart

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/24/2025 Final Jury Instructions

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/24/2025 Verdict Form

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/24/2025 Court Minutes

  • 09/24/2025 Judgment of Conviction, Retained Jurisdiction

    Judicial Officer
    Duggan (District), Barbara

  • 09/29/2025 Judgment

    Comment
    misd-resist/obstruct

  • 09/29/2025 Judgment

    Comment
    misd-para

  • 11/03/2025 Letter

    Comment
    Retained Jurisdiction Placement Letter

Loading financial, please wait...