Case Information

CR03-25-04520 | State of Idaho Plaintiff, vs. Eloy Jay Cuch Defendant.

Case Number
CR03-25-04520

Court
Bannock County District Court

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

File Date
04/21/2025

Case Type
Criminal

Case Status
Active - Pending

Party

State
State of Idaho

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney

Luca, Abe

Defendant
Cuch, Eloy Jay

DOB
XX/XX/1987

Active Attorneys

Lead Attorney

North-Shaul, Penelope

Retained

Inactive Attorneys

Attorney

State Public Defender-Bannock

Retained

Charge

Charges
Cuch, Eloy Jay

	Description	Statute	Level	Date
1	Driving Under the Influence - Previously Found Guilty of a Prior Felony Within 15 Years	I18-8005(9)	Felony	04/20/2025

2	Officer-Flee or Attempt to Elude a Police Officer in a Motor Vehicle	I49-1404(1)	Misdemeanor	04/20/2025

3	Persistent Violator	I19-2514_F	Felony	04/20/2025

Bond Settings

Setting Date
4/22/2025

Disposition Events

05/12/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Charge Number	Charge Offense Description	Description
1	Driving Under the Influence - Previously Found Guilty of a Prior Felony Within 15 Years	Not Guilty
3	Persistent Violator	Not Guilty

06/09/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Charge Number	Charge Offense Description	Description
1	Driving Under the Influence - Previously Found Guilty of a Prior Felony Within 15 Years	Guilty

04/22/2025 Plea

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.

Charge Number	Charge Offense Description	Description
2	Officer-Flee or Attempt to Elude a Police Officer in a Motor Vehicle	Not Guilty

06/09/2025 Disposition

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Charge Number	Charge Offense Description	Description
2	Officer-Flee or Attempt to Elude a Police Officer in a Motor Vehicle	Dismissed on Motion of Prosecutor
3	Persistent Violator	Dismissed on Motion of Prosecutor

Events and Hearings

04/21/2025 New Case - Criminal
04/21/2025 Criminal Complaint
04/21/2025 Affidavit of Probable Cause

Comment
Redacted
04/21/2025 Affidavit of Probable Cause

Comment
Unredacted
04/21/2025 Request

Comment
For Bond - $75,000.00
04/21/2025 Probable Cause Order

Comment
Minute Entry and Order
04/21/2025 Bond Set

Judicial Officer
Hooste, David A.

Comment
$25,000
04/21/2025 Custody Order of Sheriff

Judicial Officer
Hooste, David A.
04/21/2025 Pretrial Risk Assessment Filed
04/21/2025 Order Appointing State Public Defender
04/22/2025 Video Arraignment

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.

Hearing Time
1:30 PM

Result
Hearing Held

Parties Present

Defendant: Cuch, Eloy Jay
04/22/2025 Arraignment

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/22/2025 Notification of Rights

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/22/2025 Notification of Subsequent/Enhanced Penalties

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.

Comment
DUI
04/22/2025 Application for Public Defender

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/22/2025 Bond Set

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.

Comment
$25,000
04/22/2025 Custody Order of Sheriff

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/22/2025 Notice of Hearing

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/22/2025 Court Minutes
04/22/2025 Order Appointing State Public Defender

Judicial Officer
Hunn, Eric S.
04/24/2025 Notice of Assignment (PD)
04/24/2025 Request for Discovery

Comment
Defendant's
04/29/2025 Waiver of Preliminary Hearing
04/29/2025 Advisement of Rights - Felony Arraignment (Provided to Def.)
05/01/2025 Order Waiving Preliminary Hearing (Written Waiver)

Judicial Officer
Penrod, David
05/01/2025 Bound Over (after Prelim)
05/02/2025 Felony Information Filed

Comment
Prosecuting Attorney's Information
05/02/2025 Felony Information Part 2

Comment
Prosecuting Attorney's Information Part II - Persistent Violator
05/05/2025 Notice of Hearing
05/06/2025 Preliminary Hearing

Judicial Officer
Penrod, David

Hearing Time
9:00 AM

Cancel Reason
Vacated
05/12/2025 Arraignment - District Court

Original Type
Arraignment - District Court

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
8:30 AM

Result
Hearing Held

Parties Present

State: State of Idaho
Prosecuting Attorney: Luca, Abe
Defendant: Cuch, Eloy Jay
Public Defender: North-Shaul, Penelope
05/12/2025 Response to Request for Discovery
05/12/2025 Request for Discovery
05/12/2025 Response to Request for Discovery

Comment
Defendant's
05/12/2025 Appear & Plead Not Guilty

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
05/12/2025 Notice of Jury Trial Setting, Pretrial Conference and Order

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
05/12/2025 Court Minutes
05/21/2025 Plea Agreement
05/21/2025 Guilty Plea Advisory
05/21/2025 IDOC Agreement of Supervision
05/21/2025 PSI Face Sheet
05/21/2025 Notice of Hearing
05/21/2025 Notice of Hearing

Comment
corrected
06/02/2025 Change of Plea

Original Type
Change of Plea

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
8:30 AM

Result
Hearing Continued
06/03/2025 Court Minutes

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
06/03/2025 Notice of Hearing

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
06/03/2025 Court Minutes
06/09/2025 Change of Plea

Original Type
Change of Plea

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
8:30 AM

Result
Hearing Held
06/09/2025 Court Minutes

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
06/09/2025 Change Plea to Guilty Before Hearing/Trial

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Comment
Count I
06/09/2025 Order for Pre-Sentence Report (PSI)

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
06/09/2025 Notice of Hearing

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick
06/11/2025 Order Dismissing Charges on Motion of Prosecutor

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Comment
Count II and Part 2
08/04/2025 Sentencing

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
8:30 AM
08/18/2025 Pre-trial Conference

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
3:00 PM

Cancel Reason
Vacated
09/02/2025 Jury Trial

Judicial Officer
Carnaroli, Rick

Hearing Time
9:00 AM

Cancel Reason
Vacated

Loading financial, please wait...